By BRADLEY HOPE and TOM WRIGHT
Wall Street Journal
July 20, 2016
In 1MDB lawsuit, Justice Department trying to seize more than $1 billion in assets
U.S. prosecutors have linked the prime minister of Malaysia, a key American ally in Asia, to hundreds of millions of dollars allegedly siphoned from one of the country’s economic development funds, according to a civil lawsuit seeking the seizure of more than $1 billion of assets from other people connected to him.
The assets, purchased by the stepson of Prime Minister Najib Razak and other persons connected to the fund, include high-end real estate and hotel properties in New York City, Los Angeles and London, artwork by Vincent van Gogh and Claude Monet, and a $35 million jet. They also include rights to the 2013 film “The Wolf of Wall Street,” the civil-forfeiture complaints say.
Mr. Najib isn’t named in the filings, which were made public Wednesday, and he isn’t directly accused by U.S. prosecutors of any wrongdoing. But there are 32 references in the complaint to “Malaysian Official 1,” who allegedly received hundreds of millions of dollars in funds siphoned from 1Malaysia Development Bhd.
A person with direct knowledge of the investigation said “Malaysian Official 1” is Mr. Najib. Descriptions of the official in the filings include information about Mr. Najib’s position at 1MDB along with other identifying details.
The seizure marks a rare confrontation between U.S. prosecutors and an American ally over corruption allegations and could put in jeopardy the country’s relationship with Malaysia, a moderate Muslim nation that is a key U.S. ally in the fight against terrorism and one that serves as a counterpoint to China’s rising ambitions in Asia.
At a news conference in Washington announcing the seizures, Justice Department officials were blunt in their description of the scandal at 1MDB. “The Malaysia people were defrauded on an enormous scale,” said Deputy FBI Director Andrew McCabe. The asset seizure would be the largest ever by the Justice Department’s anticorruption effort.
The Journal reported last year how Mr. Najib played a key role in decisions at the fund, which Mr. Najib launched in 2009 to stimulate Malaysia’s economy, including issuing bonds and firing auditors.
Mr. Najib, who has denied wrongdoing, repeatedly has played down troubles at 1MDB, which has little to show for its economic development efforts despite raising $13 billion. He has said 1MDB’s real problem was an overreliance on debt that it has struggled to pay back and that “attacks” by opposition politicians hurt a planned public offering.
His administration has criticized the Journal, claiming its articles about 1MDB were false and based on “sources that may or may not exist.”
Executives at 1MDB have denied any funds were missing and echoed Mr. Najib’s claims that its primary problem was the wrong business plan. Mr. Najib and 1MDB didn’t respond to requests to comment Wednesday.
U.S. investigators paint a starkly different picture in their lawsuits, which instead describe transactions involved with 1MDB as part of “an international conspiracy to launder money.”
The documents allege that more than $3.5 billion was diverted by unnamed high-level Malaysian officials from 1MDB in three groups of transactions over several years using fraudulent documents and shell companies around the world.
A person familiar with the continuing probe said the number eventually may rise to as high as $6 billion when a full accounting is completed by authorities in multiple countries.
A Federal Bureau of Investigation criminal investigation into money laundering and fraud also is ongoing in the U.S., according to a person familiar with the probe.
Wednesday’s move marks the single largest attempted asset seizure ever under the U.S. Justice Department’s Kleptocracy Asset Recovery Initiative. It was set up in 2010 so “corrupt leaders cannot seek safe haven for their stolen wealth in the United States,” according to a State Department pamphlet.
President Barack Obama forged a relationship with Mr. Najib at a time of growing concern over China’s rise, and the two played golf together in Hawaii in 2014.
Wednesday’s action by U.S. authorities focused on assets purchased in the U.S. with the proceeds of alleged corruption.
As a result, it doesn’t seek to target any assets controlled by Mr. Najib, despite allegations by opposition politicians and people familiar with investigations in two countries that Mr. Najib received hundreds of millions of dollars in his personal bank accounts originating with 1MDB.
The complaint does allege that money from several transactions ended up in the accounts of Malaysian Official 1 from 2011 to 2013. The Journal has previously reported how more than $1 billion in total was transferred into Mr. Najib’s accounts during that period, citing bank transfer documents and people familiar with the matter.
Much of that money was transferred to offshore companies, according to bank-transfer documents reviewed by the Journal.
Mr. Najib and the Malaysian attorney general have said the money was a legal political donation from the Saudi royal family. The attorney general cleared Mr. Najib of wrongdoing and said most of the money was returned.
Saudi Arabia’s foreign minister said he was aware of a donation in April but declined to provide any other details.
The complaints filed Wednesday allege that there were three major recipients of misappropriated funds: Jho Low, a businessman and confidant of Mr. Najib’s family involved in setting up 1MDB and its subsequent dealings; Riza Aziz, stepson of Mr. Najib and a co-founder of the Los Angeles-based film company Red Granite Pictures; and Khadem Al Qubaisi, a former Abu Dhabi official whose sovereign-wealth fund was involved with 1MDB.
Wednesday’s lawsuits don’t seek to take action against any individuals, instead targeting only the property that government officials want to seize.
Mr. Aziz’s spokesman has said he has committed no wrongdoing. Mr. Al Qubaisi has declined to comment on several occasions through his lawyer. A lawyer for Mr. Low declined to comment.
Authorities in Switzerland and Singapore also have investigations into 1MDB. Both have brought sanctions against a private Swiss bank, BSI SA, that helped process many 1MDB-related transactions. BSI has said it is appealing.
Singapore prosecutors have called the 1MDB affair its largest-ever money-laundering probe.
Descriptions of the alleged frauds in the complaints raise questions for other institutions and people connected to the deals.
For instance, two of the alleged groups of transactions described by investigators relate to $6.5 billion in bonds Goldman Sachs Group Inc. raised for 1MDB. The complaint says at least $2.5 billion of that money was misappropriated by high-level 1MDB officials, their relatives and other associates.
The FBI as well as several other U.S. regulators have been investigating the role of Goldman Sachs in those deals since last year, but the investigations are at an earlier stage, according to people familiar with the inquiries. The bank has declined to comment on ongoing investigations.
The U.S. government also alleges that 1MDB’s earliest deal, a joint venture with a Saudi Arabian company called PetroSaudi International Ltd., was used to siphon away at least $1 billion. PetroSaudi repeatedly has denied any wrongdoing and said 1MDB was fully compensated with profits for the investment.
Hundreds of millions of dollars were actually diverted and used to pay gambling debts at Las Vegas casinos and to pay for yacht and jet rentals and a London interior decorator, the filings say.
Mr. Low acquired a $44.8 million luxury hotel in Beverly Hills, a $35.4 million Bombardier jet, and $151.4 million worth of luxury homes in Southern California and New York, according to the filings in a California federal court.
Money diverted from two 2012 1MDB bond offerings was used to help finance the production of “The Wolf of Wall Street” and to pay for other real estate and gambling bills, according to the filings. A portion of a subsequent 1MDB bond offering in 2013 was used within days to finance Mr. Low’s purchases, including $130 million of art from auction houses in the U.S., the filings show.
Mr. Najib still enjoys solid support in parts of Malaysia, particularly rural areas dominated by the United Malays National Organization, which has led every Malaysian government since the country’s independence from Britain in 1957, making it one of the world’s longest-ruling political parties.
Mr. Najib’s political coalition won a state election in May and has tightened its grip on the media while detaining or purging critics who have questioned his stewardship of the 1MDB fund.
Still, he has come under intense pressure from Malaysia’s opposition over the past year, which has called for his resignation.
“The seizure of assets will further swell opposition against Prime Minister Najib Razak, and encourage collaboration among those seeking to remove him from power,” said Ooi Kee Beng, deputy director of the ISEAS-Yusof Ishak Institute, a research center in Singapore. “It will also signal other countries looking into the activities of 1MDB to hasten their own investigations.”
—Celine Fernandez and Yantoultra Ngui contributed to this article.
The FBI basically said the “donation” came from 1MDB – NAJIB LIED, AG LIED, MACC failed their duties, Even BNM and Zeti failed their duties and 1MDB committed FRAUD including Arul Kanda..
What is Najib going to say now? That US has not charged him/found him guilty?? Actually the FBI has found him guilty – of breaking OUR LAWS – the monies was 1MDB and not “donation”. So the issue is IS THERE RULE OF LAW IN MALAYSIA OR NAJIB IS ABOVE THE LAW?
This Malaysian Official 1 ( Najis ) is so thick skin that he is trying to ignore. Any first world leader who have stepped down in shame. He shows once again that we are third world and that he is a third world kleptocratic despot. If he is not shame, we Malaysians are truly ashamed of him.
Hopefully some sheik of Arabia will turn up soon to save everyone.